Luck of the Draw?

/
7 Comments

In the past, I can't really remember how I felt about adoptive parents and their children. I can't remember thinking anything out of the ordinary about it. I can't remember thinking that, when I discovered someone adopted or was adopted, that I needed to make comment on the situation. Yet, I find myself in frequent odd, uncomfortable conversations with people when they realize we've adopted our daughter. (Since our daughter is a different race, you'd think it obvious, but there is a shockingly signifcant portion of the population who must be told, but I find that more entertaining than uncomfortable.)

Everyone with whom I speak always means well, so I don't really take the things they say personally, but it can still be irksome. I suppose the thing that gets under my skin the most is when a person tells me, "She'll never know how lucky she is." I don't really know how to respond to that. For one thing, we didn't adopt because we were trying to do someone a favor. If anything, we feel like we'll never know how lucky we are! Not once has anyone ever commented on how fortunate we are to have such beautiful, wonderful little girl.

On another note, we might end up being terrible parents. I hope that's not the case, and I don't think it will be the case, but if I end up being a terrible father, is she really "lucky?" Even if the Queen Bee had lived her entire childhood in the orphange, she would have been cared for and loved and prepared for life as an adult. Her situation wasn't ideal, certainly not a preferred sitaution, but it wasn't hopeless. I do hope that she is better off as a member of our family because I know we're better off with her as our daughter. I think, maybe, it's the perochialism behind the "she's so lucky" comments that bother me. She may have not been in the States, but most people aren't in the States. She may have not lived like most Americans, but most people don't. I think we're pretty good parents (I know, all parents do!), but how bad would we have to be before someone said, "She is so unlucky!"

Is a child who is placed in a family with greater wealth than what we have more lucky?

Like I said, I know people mean well, but it's a weird situation for me. I don't know what to say. I guess I'd prefer for people to recognize how luck I am to have her, if they have to say something. Or, I'd prefer that they just be happy for us and that pray that our relationships will be a blessing to each other.


You may also like

7 comments:

Jake said...

Your answer is in your post. Although I thought of a few wise acre comments you could say you summed it up nicely. "Or, I'd prefer that they just be happy for us and that pray that our relationships will be a blessing to each other."

Brian said...

I think I'd like to hear some of your wise comments before I make any final decisions ;)

Unknown said...

I think that someday she'll know how "lucky" she is, and so will you. Everyone, adopted, planned, or a surprise is blessed by the good things their parents do, and by the good people their parents might be (if that is the case --as I believe it to be with her parents).

btw - I think you should tell people that there was a mix-up at the hospital and you kept her because you liked her best¡

Unknown said...

I see where you're coming from, and I'm sure I've probably said some things to people who have adopted children that sounded misguided because I haven't experienced it and can only work from conjecture. I can only hope that they also take the attitude that you do and chalk it up to well-meaning ignorance.

The thing is, I'm not sure everyone is looking at it from the material advantages standpoint. For instance, I don't feel any sorrier for a child in an Ethiopian orphanage than I do for a child in a British or Canadian or American orphanage. It's not about being deprived of a big house and fancy toys, to me the sad part is knowing that those children don't have anyone who, for want of a better word, "belongs" to them. And they don't get the experience of "belonging" to someone. Sure, a lot of them have people who are fantastic caretakers--I can't imagine working with children every day and not loving them, but the fact is that they are paid caretakers and they might get a better job or move to another town--they are not parents. Parents, at least good parents, are devoted to the well-being of their child and they love their child in a way that even the best caretaker can't. I feel sorry for kids raised in an orphanage because emotional connections and individual attention and sense of self-worth are so hard to find in an orphanage. But I feel just as sorry for the kids in my own community who are ignored and neglected by parents who never should have had children because they are too self-centered to give them the love and attention and guidance that they need. While I was counseling at camp, I met too many kids who broke my heart with their neediness and lack of self-esteem--their souls were just starved for love and attention, and they knew that they were at camp so their parents could get rid of them for a week. If one of those kids had been adopted from an overseas orphanage, I wouldn't think that they were lucky to be adopted into a family where they would suffer the same lack of affection and attention they would in an orphanage, just in cuter clothes. To me, the luck is in the increase of love and personal attention and guidance, not the material advantages--except for the presumably better health care and education, nothing material even crosses my mind when I think about adoption. I'd like to think that most people feel the same way, but I'm afraid I'm too cynical to hope for more than 50/50 on that one.

(To be continued due to lack of space.)

Unknown said...

I often say "your baby is so blessed to have you for his/her parents" to people who I am sure will be great parents. It never occured to me that I shouldn't say that to adoptive parents because it didn't occur to me that they might think that I meant it was better for the baby to be adopted by them because he/she will have better stuff than they would in an orphanage. I just wrote it in a card to my niece and her husband. They are a broke young couple who don't have a crib or a baby swing or any of the "necessities" but they will be great parents because they will love their baby and do everything they can to raise her to be a good person who loves God and treats people with respect. There are plenty of rich people who I am certain will be abysmal parents no matter how many ponies and designer burp rags they give their kids. And I certainly wouldn't say that a child they adopted was "lucky" unless the child was literally plucked from the jaws of death or a life of slavery and prostitution. Maybe I should start saying "Your baby is so blessed to have you for parents because you will love her and nurture her and put her needs first and give her all the affection and attention she needs to grow up to be a decent human being who has respect for herself and others." Because that's really what I mean. And because of the kind of people you and Alisha are, I am confident that most of the people who tell you that Minerva is lucky really mean that she is lucky to have such loving, fun, intelligent, creative, faithful, execllent human beings for parents, especially since it seems to be such a rare thing these days.

Wow, the length of this comment tells me two things: 1) I haven't emailed or talked to you in way too long, and 2) I should probably get off the computer and go give some attention and affection to my own lucky little boys!

Brian said...

Gina, I do think that some people probably mean "lucky" in the sense you've described. I've probably not considered that seriously enough. I've probably not appreciated that enough. I have had plenty of interactions in which I knew the person did not mean this. I think the problem is that this lack of understanding puts me in a position in which I have to be the understanding one. In other words, I have to "be there" for someone else. Sometimes, it's nice when someone can "be there" for you. When someone can be understanding for you. When people regularly say stupid things in attempt to be nice or wise or whatever, and you have to "be there" for that person, you have to be understanding that they mean well, you end up being in an isolated place and that gets frustrating.

Brian said...

Ty, I think the hospital mix-up scheme is the best suggestion I've received.